• Home
  • Local Events
  • Subscribe
  • Reach Us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Login
  • Register
Upgrade
TheHomeGround Asia
  • Home
  • Singapore
  • Asia
  • World
  • Lifestyle
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • THG TV
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Singapore
  • Asia
  • World
  • Lifestyle
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • THG TV
No Result
View All Result
TheHomeGround Asia
No Result
View All Result
Home Community

Are the different perspectives and contexts of racism in Singapore at odds?

Atalia Chua by Atalia Chua
April 16, 2022
in Community, Local, Race, Singapore
Are the different perspectives and contexts of racism in Singapore at odds?

Cultural understandings of racism are diverse, not divisive. (Photo source: Canva)

0
SHARES
73
VIEWS
TheHomeGround AsiaTheHomeGround Asia

Cultural racism, unlike biological racism which is the discrimination on the basis of biological differences, is the discrimination against cultures – which includes norms, beliefs and attitudes. So while a multiracial society causes tension between races, a multicultural society causes tension between cultures. That is why intra-race racism can exist. Singapore, fortunately or unfortunately, is both. 

Cultural racism, unlike biological racism which is the discrimination on the basis of biological differences, is the discrimination against cultures – which includes norms, beliefs and attitudes.  (Photo source: Freepik)

Under this branch of racism, which is also known as ‘neo-racism’ or ‘differentialist racism’, there is a particular cultural-psychology framework: People inhabit cultural worlds that afford or promote particular racialised ways of processing and seeing the world; and people shape, produce, and maintain racialised contexts through their selected preferences, practices, and actions. 

Perceived or unintentional racism can arise from different views and understanding of what is considered offensive. Therefore, is understanding the different contexts and views of racism among different groups of people, or the conformity to a societal standard, the effective and right approach to managing racial harmony and tolerance? 

General vs targeted racism: Do they carry the same weight of offence? 

“Acknowledging the presence of certain stereotypes, or even making certain jokes need not be racist, as long as the intention is not to exclude or deride others,” says Steve Teo, a 25-year-old PhD Biological Sciences student at the National University of Singapore (NUS). 

When asked why he does not find this definition problematic, he argues that recognising the “existence of stereotypes” is “acknowledging differences among races”, and not constituted as racism. 

“For example, I think that there is some truth to the stereotype that Chinese are greedy and stingy,” Mr Teo elaborates. “I would probably not mind someone from another race pointing that out, although it is generally safer to make fun of your own race.”

Seeing the humour in stereotypes in a sense undermines them and prevents people from taking stereotypes seriously. (Photo source: Freepik)

He then explains two reasons why an open and flexible perspective on stereotypes, and in a broader sense racism, can ironically be the practical way to manage racism. 

 “We should not be afraid to discuss our differences and make fun of ourselves and each other,” he opines. “Seeing the humour in [stereotypes] in a sense undermines them, and prevents us from taking stereotypes seriously.”

This begs the question of whether Mr Teo’s argument is an example of casual racism, or about the casual recognition of racial and cultural differences. Is the embrace of one another’s learned cultural norms and lived experiences the key to unlock misunderstandings, and open the door to deeper acceptance of differences, or is it shutting people out from true multiracialism and multiculturalism?

“Some people seem to think that any acknowledgement of differences is discrimination – it shouldn’t be,” he says. “Indeed, the very tenet of our CMIO system (even if we think many aspects can and should be overhauled) sees certain differences among races as mostly fundamental, and tries to arrange our socio-political structures around it, rather than try to eliminate all differences.” 

The Chinese-Malay-Indian-Others model is ‘the basis of a racialised mode of ethnic governance, which is based on the notion that separate management of racial groups ensures optimal functioning of society.’ 

Oversensitivity about identity, itself a defensive reaction in the face of standardisation, is aggravating insular attitudes based on the notion of nation and race. (Photo source: Scientific American)

In a publication titled Dimensions of Racism by the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner of Human Rights, it states that “oversensitivity about identity, itself a defensive reaction in the face of standardisation, is aggravating insular attitudes based on the notion of nation, community, group, race, religion, way of life and lifestyle.”

The problem of how this gives rise to new forms of racism is by refusing to recognise the ‘negative images of the “other” and that will ‘evolve in the cultural domain’. This causes a more severe repression of expression in people, which will in turn be manifested in “self-justification and their most radical forms of expression”. 

Acknowledging stereotypes, however, is conditional and “highly situational,” Mr Teo cautions. Localised contexts and personal intentions are the determining factors. 

Firstly, “among Singaporeans, our understanding of what constitutes a ‘racist remark’ could be different from that of a liberal Western context”. In other words, he thinks that these could be instances when people mention something related to race, without the nuances of pregnant racism.

Different cultural understandings does not excuse targeted racism though: “The intention and effect should not be to exclude or discriminate.” Mr Teo asserts. “If that stereotype is used to suggest that I am greedy and stingy, because I am Chinese, or if that stereotype is used to exclude me in some way, [then to me] that is racism.”

Associate Professor Tan Ern Ser, a sociologist at the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy at NUS, agrees with this and puts it in perspective: “Cultural stereotypes [are different] from nuances. The latter comes across as objective characteristics peculiar to an ‘outgroup’; but in practice, it is our subjective perception of ‘other groups’ that could lead to racism,” he says.  

All forms of casual racism should not be accepted

Casual racism has been a tricky branch of racism to diagnose. According to the Australian Human Rights Commission (AHRC), “casual racism refers to conduct involving negative stereotypes or prejudices about people on the basis of race, colour or ethnicity, [such as in] jokes, off-handed comments, and exclusion of people from social situations on the basis of race.” 

The fine line between that and traditional racism is the “intention to cause offence or harm”. 

Casual racism is still racism. (Photo source: Redbubble)

Jose Raymond, 50, and Chief Strategy Officer at strategy and communications advisory firm SW Strategies agrees: “Racism in all forms is unacceptable,” he states. 

He was also the ex-Chairman of opposition political party Singapore People’s Party before retiring from politics, last December. 

“Casual racism has always existed in many forms, from racial slurs [to] stereotypes [about Indians], such as ‘Indians coming to catch naughty children’, among other instances,” Mr Raymond continues. He feels that a line needs to be drawn to say that even as a ‘joke’, or in ‘casual settings’, racism is not tolerated. 

Eurasian Tau Kaijun Bowyer, 19, who is pursuing a Diploma in Audio Engineering at LASALLE, shares these sentiments: “[I get] called ‘angmoh’ all the time. We live with [casual racism] now, but in the long run…I hope younger parents can teach their children better,” he shares. “Racism is not natural, it is learned; it’s not alright but it will take time to fix.”

Although it may not be intended racism, the AHRC writes that ‘racism is as much about impact as it is about intention’. “[We] shouldn’t forget about those who are on the receiving end of discrimination.”

Awareness of differences includes deliberate effort in showing respect

Understanding the importance of a cultural tradition or religious practice of various ethnicities is one of the key ways to show respect, suggests Siti Ismail, a 38-year-old marketing manager. 

“One example will be offering dishes which are non-halal or contain pork to me,” she shares. “Most of the time, this happens because the other person forgets that I don’t consume [these]. It may seem harmless but I do get affected by it at times.”

Understanding the importance of a cultural tradition or religious practice to a race is one of the key ways to show respect. (Photo source: The Wall Street Journal)

Making a conscious effort to be aware that there are other races around is another way to prevent disrespect, unhappiness and misunderstanding. Hence, speaking in one’s mother’s tongue is a common thorn in every race’s side. “As a Malay, I do take offence when other races [speak] in their native language in front of me,” Ms Ismail says. “When they do that, I often feel that either they were trying to exclude me from their discussion, or they were keeping something from me.”

Mr Teo expresses the same sentiments and warns people against it: “[That is a] commonly cited example [that seems discriminatory]. Sometimes, people are not seeking to exclude, but are just being careless, or are simply more proficient in their own language,” he explains. 

To minimise such misunderstandings, he says that making an effort to switch to English when someone of another race is around, and making sure they can be included in the conversation, is “basic politeness”. He recognises that many Singaporeans do practise that and are “by and large gracious”. 

Since Singapore is a multiracial and multicultural society, cross-ethnic understanding can truly foster a greater appreciation of various cultural values and practices. But besides that, “adherence to a common [national] set of values [is] essential [in] producing inter-ethnic acceptance and harmony,” says Associate Professor Tan. He thinks that this is effective in curbing racism, because it “means subscribing to a set of superordinate [national] values, practices, and purpose.” 

According to Dr Tan, it is worthwhile to note that a cosmopolitan and multiracial society does not cause racism, and does not automatically promote prejudice. 

He argues, “It is only when diversity is somehow perceived as a threat [that] it could exacerbate racism, intolerance and conflict.” He advises instead that the key to a “high degree of social integration and harmony” is the “orientation towards embracing diversity.” 

In the last part of TheHomeGround Asia’s series on racism, we examine the differences among racism, cultural insensitivity and cultural appropriation. The interchangeable or conflated nature of these issues have become dangerous with irreversible consequences. 

Join the conversations on TheHomeGround Asia’s Facebook and Instagram, and get the latest updates via Telegram. 

Previous Post

Eschewing mainstream educational environments for homeschooling

Next Post

Social service sector going digital to better serve the social needs of communities

Atalia Chua

Atalia Chua

Related Posts

Familiarity Breeds Votes: Why PAP’s Ground Presence Won GE2025 – and What the Opposition Must Learn
Local

Familiarity Breeds Votes: Why PAP’s Ground Presence Won GE2025 – and What the Opposition Must Learn

by Kevin Wong
May 6, 2025
GE2025 and the Politics of “Losing an Office Holder”: A Voter’s Dilemma or a False Binary?
Local

GE2025 and the Politics of “Losing an Office Holder”: A Voter’s Dilemma or a False Binary?

by Kevin Wong
May 4, 2025
Tudung Policy Change: Without Ground Pressure and Alternative Voices, Would Progress in Singapore Have Come?
Local

Tudung Policy Change: Without Ground Pressure and Alternative Voices, Would Progress in Singapore Have Come?

by Kevin Wong
May 4, 2025
From Walkover to Walk Forward: How Workers’ Party Can Turn Crisis into Opportunity
Local

From Walkover to Walk Forward: How Workers’ Party Can Turn Crisis into Opportunity

by Kevin Wong
April 25, 2025
Young, Vocal, and Ready to Vote: The Political Pulse of Singapore’s Youth
Local

Young, Vocal, and Ready to Vote: The Political Pulse of Singapore’s Youth

by Kevin Wong
April 22, 2025
Next Post
Social service sector going digital to better serve the social needs of communities

Social service sector going digital to better serve the social needs of communities

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Premium Content

2020 Super Netball & Constellations Cup is On; Quad Series is Off

May 4, 2025
After Last Season’s Win, Swifts Are Ready To Start New Season Strong

After Last Season’s Win, Swifts Are Ready To Start New Season Strong

November 27, 2020
I Tried Making The Famous No-Knead Bread. Here Are The Results.

I Tried Making The Famous No-Knead Bread. Here Are The Results.

March 22, 2021

TheHomeGround

TheHomeGround Asia

We are an inclusive digital news platform that tells credible, authentic, in-depth human-interest stories of hope, passion, resilience and triumph, holding space for voices that might otherwise be marginalised, displaced, ignored or simply unheard.

THG Sections

  • Home
  • Singapore
  • Asia
  • World
  • Lifestyle
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • THG TV

About THG

  • About Us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Reach Us

Follow Our Stories

© 2025 THG - Authentic, in-depth human-interest stories .

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Singapore
  • Asia
  • World
  • Lifestyle
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • THG TV

© 2025 THG - Authentic, in-depth human-interest stories .

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?